Last confirmed active 18 days ago — it may be under contract or sold since. Check the official listing before you act. Verify on Zillow · Redfin · Realtor.com
1 / 6
19score
$359,900
MLS
Street view4537 Sugar Bay Ln
Indianapolis IN 46237 · Single Family · built 2003
4 bd2.5 ba2,851 sqft$126/sqft vs ZIP $151 −16%
0.74 lender DSCR (est.)
Rent covers the estimated payment 0.74× · walk-away floor 1.20 · medium confidence
How we compute this
Rent est. $2,043/mo (ZIP + bedroom comps) ÷ estimated monthly payment: 75% LTV, ~7.5% rate, 30‑yr term, insurance ~0.5%/yr, taxes from the county assessor. Assumptions as of 2026-09-12.
17% under ZIP $/sqftbelow assessed value
The underwriting
The numbers (estimates, illustrative)
$359,900List price
$2,043Rent estimate / mo
0.74Lender DSCR (est.)
$8,366Taxes / yr · county assessor
$151ZIP median $ / sqft
19/100Deal Score
Monthly picture (illustrative)
| Rent est. | $2,043 |
| − Mortgage (P&I) | −$1,887 |
| − Taxes | −$697 |
| − Insurance | −$150 |
| − HOA | −$27 |
| = Cash flow before vacancy & repairs | $-718 |
The numbers
- Price
- $359,900
- $ / sq ft
- $126 ZIP median $151
- Rent estimate
- $2,043/mo ZIP + bedroom comps
- Property taxes
- $8,366/yr 2% cap on assessed value $418,300
- PITIA (assumed)
- $2,761/mo 75% LTV at ~7.5% over 30 yr, taxes, insurance 0.5%/yr, HOA $27/mo
- Lender DSCR (est.)
- 0.74 rent ÷ PITIA · lender floor 1.20
- Deal Score
- 19/100 17% under ZIP $/sqft · below assessed value
The property
- Beds / baths
- 4 / 2.5
- Living area
- 2,851 sq ft
- Lot
- 11,326 sq ft
- Year built
- 2003
- Property type
- Single Family
- HOA
- $27/mo
- Flood zone
- None (Zone X)
- Registered rental
- No
The listing
- Source
- Standard
- MLS #
- 22123392
- Listed
- Sep 1, 2026
- Days on market
- 32
- Listing agent
- Nicole Bland Burks · Fathom Realty
3176912544 · nicoleb@onedream.house - Price history
- First asked $359,900
Keep looking
Similar deals nearby
Ask Triad about this deal
Want a second opinion, a walkthrough, or an offer strategy?
We buy in Indianapolis ourselves. Tell us what you're thinking and our team replies within one business day. Free, no obligation.
All figures are illustrative estimates from the list price, public records, rent comps / HUD fair-market rent and assumed financing (75% LTV, ~7.5%, 30 yr, as of 2026-09-12). Not verified, not an offer, not investment advice. Triad Global, LLC is a real-estate investor, not a licensed brokerage. Listing data from public sources; verify everything before you bid. Equal Housing Opportunity.